Updated October 18, 2026 · 22 stores, each checked against its own website
The best mattress stores in and near Carmel are Kittle's Indianapolis, American Mattress Indianapolis and Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 86th Street). We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, then by how many of their delivery, old-bed removal and return policies they post, counting one location per chain. We checked 22 stores within 8 miles of central Carmel, and no store pays to be listed.
A few minutes on a showroom bed will not tell you how it feels after a month at home. Pick a bed you trust from a store whose exchange and return policy you can live with: only 10 of the 22 stores here post a policy that lets you return a bed.
We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, then by how many of their delivery, old-bed removal and return policies they post, counting one location per chain. Ties after that go to the closer store, and stores cannot pay to be ranked.
Each pick comes from the facts below, not from payments. Tap one to jump to the store.
Sorted by distance from central Carmel. Filter by what matters to you.
Showing 22 of 22 stores
No store matches all of these. Try removing a filter.
Local store · Central Carmel
1.4 mi from central Carmel
(317) 848-2939200 S. Rangeline Road Suite 119, Carmel, IN 46032
| Mon | 10 am-5 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-5 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-5 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-5 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-5 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-5 pm |
| Sun | Closed |
Not listed by the store: brands, bed types, delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page. Report an error
Furniture store · Central Carmel
1.4 mi from central Carmel
(317) 566-872013610 North Meridian St, Carmel, IN 46032
| Mon | 9 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 9 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 9 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 9 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-6 pm |
| Sun | 12 pm-5 pm |
Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Store locator, Mattresses. Report an error
Chain store · Northeast Carmel
2.5 mi from central Carmel
(463) 223-606014511 Clay Terrace Boulevard Suite 100, Carmel, IN 46032
Sleep Number® mattresses and bases are delivered through our Home Delivery Options, which may include professional delivery and setup depending on the service selected.
Removal and disposal depend on your delivery type and whether disposal was added to your order.
Mattresses can be returned through: Calling our Customer Service Center
| Mon | 10 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-7 pm |
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Carmel store page, Delivery and shipping policy, Old mattress removal policy, Returns and exchanges policy. Report an error
Chain store · Northeast Carmel
2.8 mi from central Carmel
(317) 571-018614641 Thatcher Lane Suite 9, Carmel, IN 46032
If you order a mattress for delivery through Mattress Firm, unwanted mattress removal is part of the delivery service.
| Mon | 9 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 9 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 9 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 9 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 9 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 10 am-6 pm |
Not listed by the store: brands, bed types, delivery, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress Firm mattress removal information. Report an error
Local maker · Indianapolis
4.1 mi from central Carmel
(317) 559-06168702 Keystone Crossing, Ste 135, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Once you're satisfied, we'll place your custom order here in the store, make it locally in our facility, and ship it for free right to your doorstep.
For up to 120 days after the delivery of your mattress, we will we partner with you to reconstruct your mattress as many times as necessary until we get it right. And if we never do, we'll refund your purchase in full.
| Mon | 10 am-7 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-7 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-7 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-7 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-7 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-7 pm |
| Sun | 12 pm-5 pm |
Not listed by the store: old-bed removal. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress appointment and address, Trial and warranty policy, Foam types. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
4.3 mi from central Carmel
(317) 253-12393357 East 86th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Delivery where you want - front door, side door or even garage
Removal of old mattress set (equal to the number of pieces purchased)*
Sleep on it for 120 nights - if you don't love it, we'll help you find a new one or your money back.
| Mon | 10 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 10 am-6 pm |
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Delivery and haul-away details. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
4.7 mi from central Carmel
(317) 779-39193949 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Returns must be reviewed and approved before any product is returned or picked up.
| Mon | 10 am-7 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-7 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-7 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-7 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-7 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-7 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-6 pm |
Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Indianapolis store page, Mattress collection, Refund policy. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
4.9 mi from central Carmel
(317) 913-71824205 East 82nd Street, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Premium and Ultimate Home Delivery options include in-home delivery and full assembly. Doorstep Delivery is available for customers who prefer self-installation.
Removal and disposal depend on your delivery type and whether disposal was added to your order.
If you are not completely satisfied with your product, you may contact us within your 100-night In-Home Trial to arrange for a one-time exchange of your purchase.
| Mon | 10 am-7 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-7 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-7 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-7 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-7 pm |
Not listed by the store: bed types. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Delivery and shipping policy, Delivery reminders and removal policy, Returns and exchanges policy. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
5.3 mi from central Carmel
(317) 594-59004909 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Deliveries can be made within 24-48 hours of your purchase, within a 2 hour delivery window.
We'll even remove your old mattress set for you.
If you are not satisfied with your purchase, you may return the product within 48 hours of receiving it.
| Mon | 10 am-7:30 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-7:30 pm |
| Wed | 11 am-6 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-7:30 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-7:30 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-7 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-6 pm |
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Shipping and returns policy, Serta collection, Tempur-Pedic collection, Purple collection, Stearns & Foster collection. Report an error
Furniture store · Indianapolis
5.3 mi from central Carmel
(317) 849-53008600 Allisonville Rd., Indianapolis, IN 46250
Upon notification that your merchandise has been received in the warehouse, your furniture must be scheduled for delivery or pick up within 30 days.
Upon delivery of mattress purchases, we do offer to pick-up your used mattress and boxspring for a small recycle fee.
Except for fabric samples and loaner rugs, no returns will be accepted after merchandise is delivered or picked up.
| Mon | 11 am-7 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 11 am-7 pm |
| Wed | 11 am-7 pm |
| Thu | 11 am-7 pm |
| Fri | 11 am-7 pm |
| Sat | 11 am-7 pm |
| Sun | 12 pm-6 pm |
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress selection, Delivery options, Policies. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
5.3 mi from central Carmel
(317) 284-90948603 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Full-service delivery to your room of choice, unpacking, assembly, trash removal and more.
If you order a new mattress or foundation and have it delivered via BOBtastic White Glove delivery, Bob's will haul away your old mattress and foundation at no additional cost on the day your new items are delivered if your old items are in safe and sanitary condition.
You may return your mattress within 90 days of the original receipt date and we will refund the purchase price minus the original delivery fee.
| Mon | 10 am-9 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-9 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-9 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-9 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-9 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-9 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-7 pm |
Not listed by the store: brands, bed types. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Delivery information, Mattress haul-away FAQ, Returns and exchanges policy. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
5.5 mi from central Carmel
(317) 608-58078708 Castle Creek Parkway East Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46250
In-store purchases, whether from independently owned and operated stores or from stores owned and operated by Ashley Global Retail, LLC or subsidiaries, set their own policies regarding returns and exchanges.
| Mon | 10 am-9 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-9 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-9 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-9 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-9 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-9 pm |
| Sun | 12 pm-8 pm |
Not listed by the store: bed types, delivery, old-bed removal. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Official Ashley returns policy. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
5.5 mi from central Carmel
(317) 598-84508516 Castleton Corner Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46250
After the delivery team delivers your mattress and sets up all items purchased from Mattress Firm, the team will remove or relocate your existing mattress and box spring on a one-for-one basis within your home.
| Mon | 10 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 10 am-6 pm |
Not listed by the store: bed types, delivery, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress Firm mattress removal information. Report an error
Furniture store · Indianapolis
5.5 mi from central Carmel
(317) 956-58028401 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46268
| Mon | 10 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-6 pm |
Not listed by the store: brands, bed types, delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Official store site. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
5.6 mi from central Carmel
(317) 284-11215305 E 82 St., Indianapolis, IN 46250
| Mon | 10 am-7 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-7 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-7 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-7 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-7 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-6 pm |
| Sun | 12 pm-4 pm |
Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Bowles mattresses, Long's home page. Report an error
Outlet · Indianapolis
5.7 mi from central Carmel
(317) 390-45377225 N. Keystone Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46240
If you are unsatisfied for any reason with your purchase, you can return or exchange it within 30 days of delivery.
| Mon | 10 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-6 pm |
Not listed by the store: brands, bed types, delivery, old-bed removal. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress category, Return policy. Report an error
Furniture store · Indianapolis
5.7 mi from central Carmel
(317) 578-77708375 CASTLETON CORNER DR., Indianapolis, IN 46250
| Mon | 10 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-6 pm |
Not listed by the store: brands, bed types, delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
6.1 mi from central Carmel
(317) 849-65006020 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Yes! Get our White Glove Delivery service with any mattress purchase (for free on mattress purchases $699 & up) within the 48 contiguous United States.
We will remove your old mattress for a $25 fee.
Mattresses must be returned within 120 days of delivery.
| Mon | 10 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-9 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-9 pm |
| Sun | 11 am-6 pm |
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress customer care and removal policy, Furniture and mattress return policy. Report an error
Furniture store · Indianapolis
6.1 mi from central Carmel
(317) 337-14004625 W. 86th St. Ste #600, Indianapolis, IN 46268
This means that the risk of loss and title for such items pass to you upon our delivery to the carrier.
| Mon | Closed |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-7 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-6 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-7 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-6 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-5 pm |
| Sun | Closed |
Not listed by the store: bed types, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Official mattress listing and Kingsdown, Official terms shown on manufacturers page, Official store invitation and walk-in information. Report an error
Furniture store · Westfield
6.4 mi from central Carmel
(317) 678-75273276 IN-32, Westfield, IN 46074
At My Comfy Casa Mattress & Furniture, all sales are final.
| Mon | 11:30 am-6 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 11:30 am-6 pm |
| Wed | 11:30 am-5 pm |
| Thu | 11:30 am-6 pm |
| Fri | 11 am-6 pm |
| Sat | 11:30 am-6 pm |
| Sun | Closed |
Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Official mattress collection, Official adjustable bases collection, Official refund policy. Report an error
Chain store · Indianapolis
6.9 mi from central Carmel
(317) 252-57942605 East 62nd Street Suite 1004 through 1006, Indianapolis, IN 46220
| Mon | 10 am-8 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10 am-8 pm |
| Wed | 10 am-8 pm |
| Thu | 10 am-8 pm |
| Fri | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sat | 10 am-8 pm |
| Sun | 10 am-6 pm |
Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page. Report an error
Local store · Zionsville
6.9 mi from central Carmel
(317) 733-64061231 W. Oak St, Zionsville, IN 46077
| Mon | 10:30 am-7 pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 10:30 am-7 pm |
| Wed | 10:30 am-7 pm |
| Thu | 10:30 am-7 pm |
| Fri | 10:30 am-7 pm |
| Sat | 10:30 am-5:30 pm |
| Sun | 12 pm-5 pm |
Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.
Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Village Mattress types, Village Mattress brands and in-store service. Report an error
The fine print is where stores differ most: delivery, old-bed removal and return fees.
Swipe sideways to see every column.
| Store | Distance | Delivery | Old bed | Returns | Sunday |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Indianapolis Metro | 1.4 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Closed |
| Carmel Showroom | 1.4 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | 12 pm-5 pm |
| Sleep Number Northeast | 2.5 mi | Sleep Number® mattresses and bases are delivered through our Home Delivery Options,... Full text | Removal and disposal depend on your delivery type and whether disposal was added to... Full text | Mattresses can be returned through: Calling our Customer Service Center | 11 am-7 pm |
| Mattress Firm Northeast | 2.8 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | If you order a mattress for delivery through Mattress Firm, unwanted mattress removal... Full text | Not listed. Call to ask. | 10 am-6 pm |
| Comfort Option at the Keystone Fashion Mall in Indianapolis | 4.1 mi | Once you're satisfied, we'll place your custom order here in the store, make it locally... Full text | Not listed. Call to ask. | For up to 120 days after the delivery of your mattress, we will we partner with you to... Full text | 12 pm-5 pm |
| Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 86th Street) | 4.3 mi | Delivery where you want - front door, side door or even garage | Removal of old mattress set (equal to the number of pieces purchased)* | Sleep on it for 120 nights - if you don't love it, we'll help you find a new one or... Full text | 10 am-6 pm |
| Snooze Mattress + Wellness | 4.7 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Returns must be reviewed and approved before any product is returned or picked up. | 11 am-6 pm |
| Sleep Number Indianapolis | 4.9 mi | Premium and Ultimate Home Delivery options include in-home delivery and full assembly.... Full text | Removal and disposal depend on your delivery type and whether disposal was added to... Full text | If you are not completely satisfied with your product, you may contact us within your... Full text | 11 am-7 pm |
| American Mattress Indianapolis | 5.3 mi | Deliveries can be made within 24-48 hours of your purchase, within a 2 hour delivery... Full text | We'll even remove your old mattress set for you. | If you are not satisfied with your purchase, you may return the product within 48 hours... Full text | 11 am-6 pm |
| Kittle's Indianapolis | 5.3 mi | Upon notification that your merchandise has been received in the warehouse, your... Full text | Upon delivery of mattress purchases, we do offer to pick-up your used mattress and... Full text | Except for fabric samples and loaner rugs, no returns will be accepted after... Full text | 12 pm-6 pm |
| Bob's Discount Furniture Indianapolis | 5.3 mi | Full-service delivery to your room of choice, unpacking, assembly, trash removal and more. | If you order a new mattress or foundation and have it delivered via BOBtastic White... Full text | You may return your mattress within 90 days of the original receipt date and we will... Full text | 11 am-7 pm |
| Ashley Indianapolis | 5.5 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | In-store purchases, whether from independently owned and operated stores or from stores... Full text | 12 pm-8 pm |
| Mattress Firm Indianapolis (Castleton Corner Drive) | 5.5 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | After the delivery team delivers your mattress and sets up all items purchased from... Full text | Not listed. Call to ask. | 10 am-6 pm |
| Half Price Furniture Outlet (Michigan Rd) | 5.5 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | 11 am-6 pm |
| Long's Mattress | Castleton | 5.6 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | 12 pm-4 pm |
| Half Price Furniture Outlet (N. Keystone Avenue) | 5.7 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | If you are unsatisfied for any reason with your purchase, you can return or exchange it... Full text | 11 am-6 pm |
| Urban Styles Furniture | 5.7 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | 11 am-6 pm |
| JCPenney Indianapolis | 6.1 mi | Yes! Get our White Glove Delivery service with any mattress purchase (for free on... Full text | We will remove your old mattress for a $25 fee. | Mattresses must be returned within 120 days of delivery. | 11 am-6 pm |
| Direct Plus, Inc. | 6.1 mi | This means that the risk of loss and title for such items pass to you upon our delivery... Full text | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Closed |
| My Comfy Casa Mattress & Furniture | 6.4 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | At My Comfy Casa Mattress & Furniture, all sales are final. | Closed |
| Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 62nd Street Suite 1004 through 1006) | 6.9 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | 10 am-6 pm |
| Village Mattress | 6.9 mi | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | Not listed. Call to ask. | 12 pm-5 pm |
Want to lie on a certain bed before you buy it? Find every checked store that lists it, then call ahead to make sure it is on the floor.
We searched every ZIP code within 8 miles of central Carmel for stores. Distances are straight-line miles from the middle of each ZIP code.
| ZIP | Stores within 5 mi | Nearest store | What is close by |
|---|---|---|---|
| 46032 | 5 | Carmel Showroom, 2.2 mi | 5 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Serta, Sleep Number. |
| 46033 | 12 | Indianapolis Metro, 2.2 mi | 12 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Tempur-Pedic, Beautyrest, Sealy. |
| 46038 | 6 | Ashley Indianapolis, 4.5 mi | 6 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Sealy, Serta, Tempur-Pedic. |
| 46074 | 5 | My Comfy Casa Mattress & Furniture, 2.1 mi | 5 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Ashley Sleep®, Beautyrest, Nectar. |
| 46077 | 1 | Village Mattress, 2.4 mi | 1 store is within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Sealy, Stearns & Foster, Tempur-Pedic. |
| 46220 | 14 | Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 62nd Street Suite 1004 through 1006), 0.6 mi | 14 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Tempur-Pedic, Beautyrest, Sealy. |
| 46240 | 15 | Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 86th Street), 0.9 mi | 15 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Tempur-Pedic, Beautyrest, Sealy. |
| 46250 | 14 | JCPenney Indianapolis, 0.5 mi | 14 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Tempur-Pedic, Beautyrest, Sealy. |
| 46260 | 9 | Half Price Furniture Outlet (Michigan Rd), 2.4 mi | 9 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Tempur-Pedic, Sealy. |
| 46268 | 3 | Direct Plus, Inc., 0.9 mi | 3 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Kingsdown, Sealy, Stearns & Foster. |
| 46280 | 19 | Comfort Option at the Keystone Fashion Mall in Indianapolis, 2.0 mi | 19 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Tempur-Pedic, Sealy. |
| 46290 | 15 | Comfort Option at the Keystone Fashion Mall in Indianapolis, 3.2 mi | 15 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Tempur-Pedic, Serta. |
"Special pickup for these items include an additional fee of $20.00 per item to be paid by the resident. ... Please contact Republic Services at least 48 hours prior to your normal pickup day if you have a heavy or bulky item." See the full rules and how to schedule on the source page.
Source: Carmel Utilities - Trash, checked October 18, 2026.
Hamilton County sales tax is 7.00% (Indiana's state rate), so a $1,000 mattress costs $70 in tax.
Source: Indiana Department of Revenue, sales tax, checked October 18, 2026.
Lie down in the position you sleep in. Bring your own pillow. Ask for the exact model name on paper so you can compare it with other stores.
19 of the 22 stores we checked open on Sunday: Carmel Showroom (12 pm to 5 pm), Sleep Number Northeast (11 am to 7 pm), Mattress Firm Northeast (10 am to 6 pm), Comfort Option at the Keystone Fashion Mall in Indianapolis (12 pm to 5 pm), Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 86th Street) (10 am to 6 pm), Snooze Mattress + Wellness (11 am to 6 pm), Sleep Number Indianapolis (11 am to 7 pm), American Mattress Indianapolis (11 am to 6 pm), Kittle's Indianapolis (12 pm to 6 pm), Bob's Discount Furniture Indianapolis (11 am to 7 pm), Ashley Indianapolis (12 pm to 8 pm), Mattress Firm Indianapolis (Castleton Corner Drive) (10 am to 6 pm), Half Price Furniture Outlet (Michigan Rd) (11 am to 6 pm), Long's Mattress | Castleton (12 pm to 4 pm), Half Price Furniture Outlet (N. Keystone Avenue) (11 am to 6 pm), Urban Styles Furniture (11 am to 6 pm), JCPenney Indianapolis (11 am to 6 pm), Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 62nd Street Suite 1004 through 1006) (10 am to 6 pm), Village Mattress (12 pm to 5 pm). Hours were checked on the dates shown on each store.
9 checked stores list Tempur-Pedic on their own sites: Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 86th Street) in Indianapolis, Snooze Mattress + Wellness in Indianapolis, American Mattress Indianapolis in Indianapolis, Kittle's Indianapolis in Indianapolis, Ashley Indianapolis in Indianapolis, Mattress Firm Indianapolis (Castleton Corner Drive) in Indianapolis, JCPenney Indianapolis in Indianapolis, Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 62nd Street Suite 1004 through 1006) in Indianapolis, Village Mattress in Zionsville. Call ahead to make sure it is on the showroom floor.
7 checked stores list Beautyrest on their own sites: Carmel Showroom in Central Carmel, Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 86th Street) in Indianapolis, Snooze Mattress + Wellness in Indianapolis, American Mattress Indianapolis in Indianapolis, Mattress Firm Indianapolis (Castleton Corner Drive) in Indianapolis, JCPenney Indianapolis in Indianapolis, Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 62nd Street Suite 1004 through 1006) in Indianapolis. Call ahead to make sure it is on the showroom floor.
No. We list every store that passes our checks, sorted by distance. Picks are based on the facts shown, such as hours, brands and published policies.