The best mattress stores in and near Noblesville, Indiana
Updated October 18, 2026 · 8 stores, each checked against its own website
The best mattress stores in and near Noblesville are Mattress Firm Carmel, JCPenney Southeast and Sleep Number Southeast. We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, then by how many of their delivery, old-bed removal and return policies they post, counting one location per chain. We checked 8 stores within 8 miles of central Noblesville, and no store pays to be listed.
Mattress Firm Carmel: 7 brands to try, including Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster and Purple. Carmel, 7 mi, open Sunday; old-bed removal offered, publishes a return policy.
JCPenney Southeast: 5 brands to try, including Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster and Sealy. Southeast Noblesville, 4.9 mi, open Sunday; old-bed removal offered, publishes a return policy.
Sleep Number Southeast: 1 brand to try: Sleep Number. Southeast Noblesville, 4.7 mi, open Sunday; old-bed removal offered, publishes a return policy.
A few minutes on a showroom bed will not tell you how it feels after a month at home. Pick a bed you trust from a store whose exchange and return policy you can live with: only 3 of the 8 stores here post a policy that lets you return a bed.
We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, then by how many of their delivery, old-bed removal and return policies they post, counting one location per chain. Ties after that go to the closer store, and stores cannot pay to be ranked.
Quick picks
Best Noblesville stores for what you need
Each pick comes from the facts below, not from payments. Tap one to jump to the store.
(317) 776-672413976 Town Center Boulevard Suite 700, Noblesville, IN 46060
Open Sunday
Adjustable bases
Brands
Sleep Number
Bed types
Adjustable base
Delivery
Premium and Ultimate: Our team will assemble your smart bed, connect it to Wi-Fi (Smart Beds only) and show you how everything works (Ultimate also includes mattress disposal and relocation.)
Old bed
If you did not purchase an optional disposal or an ultimate delivery, please remove your old mattress the day of delivery.
Returns
Mattresses can be returned through: Calling our Customer Service Center
Yes! Get our White Glove Delivery service with any mattress purchase (for free on mattress purchases $699 & up) within the 48 contiguous United States.
Old bed
Delivery fees and Mattress Haul Away Service fees are non-refundable.
Returns
Mattresses must be returned within 120 days of delivery.
At Mattress Firm, delivering your new bed to your doorstep is always free, regardless of if you bought the mattress online or in-store.
Old bed
After the delivery team delivers your mattress and sets up all items purchased from Mattress Firm, the team will remove or relocate your existing mattress and box spring on a one-for-one basis within your home.
Returns
Subject to the above guidelines, our 120 Night Sleep Trial is valid for one exchange and/or one return per purchase, which must be done within 120 days of the delivery date of your originally purchased mattress.
Lie down in the position you sleep in. Bring your own pillow. Ask for the exact model name on paper so you can compare it with other stores.
Questions
Questions about mattress stores in Noblesville
Which mattress stores in Noblesville are open on Sunday?
8 of the 8 stores we checked open on Sunday: Long's Mattress (12 pm to 4 pm), Noblesville/Fishers (12 pm to 5 pm), Mattress Firm Southeast (10 am to 6 pm), Sleep Number Southeast (11 am to 7 pm), JCPenney Southeast (11 am to 7 pm), Mattress Firm Carmel (10 am to 6 pm), Kittle's Outlet Fishers (12 pm to 6 pm), Mattress Firm Fishers (10 am to 6 pm). Hours were checked on the dates shown on each store.
Where can I try Sealy in Noblesville?
4 checked stores list Sealy on their own sites: Mattress Firm Southeast in Southeast Noblesville, JCPenney Southeast in Southeast Noblesville, Mattress Firm Carmel in Carmel, Mattress Firm Fishers in Fishers. Call ahead to make sure it is on the showroom floor.
Where can I try Tempur-Pedic in Noblesville?
4 checked stores list Tempur-Pedic on their own sites: Mattress Firm Southeast in Southeast Noblesville, JCPenney Southeast in Southeast Noblesville, Mattress Firm Carmel in Carmel, Mattress Firm Fishers in Fishers. Call ahead to make sure it is on the showroom floor.
Do stores pay to be on this page?
No. We list every store that passes our checks, sorted by distance. Picks are based on the facts shown, such as hours, brands and published policies.
How we check
How we built this list
Every fact has a source. Hours, brands and policies come from the store's own website. Each store links its sources. We do not print prices, because they change too often to keep right.
Two checks per store. A search finds the store. Then a script opens the store's own page and confirms the street address and phone number are on it, and that every policy line we quote is still there word for word. A store that fails is left off. Checks used for this page: Script check against the store's website; Store search (AI). The date on each store is the latest check.
Open stores only. We confirm each store is open within 90 days of the update date. Closed stores come off the page.
Within 8 miles. We only list stores within 8 miles of central Noblesville.
No paid spots. Stores cannot pay to be listed or ranked. We do not test mattresses in a lab; we compare the facts stores publish.
