Mattress stores in Indiana
Pick a city to see the mattress stores in and near it, with hours, the brands you can try in person, and each store's delivery, old-bed removal and returns policies. 278 stores in 17 cities, updated October 18, 2026.
We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, then by how many of their delivery, old-bed removal and return policies they post, counting one location per chain. A few minutes on a showroom bed will not tell you how it feels after a month at home. Pick a bed you trust from a store whose exchange and return policy you can live with: only 121 of the 278 stores here post a policy that lets you return a bed.
- Indianapolis53 stores
- Carmel22 stores
- Fort Wayne21 stores
- Lawrence20 stores
- Gary17 stores
- Evansville16 stores
- Fishers15 stores
- South Bend14 stores
- Greenwood14 stores
- Mishawaka13 stores
- Westfield12 stores
- Hammond11 stores
- Lafayette11 stores
- Jeffersonville11 stores
- Bloomington10 stores
- Terre Haute10 stores
- Noblesville8 stores
Mattress stores in Indianapolis
We checked 53 stores within 15 miles of central Indianapolis. Of those, 44 are open on Sunday and 24 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Best Value Mattress Warehouse: 13 brands to try, Northwest Indianapolis, 11.1 mi
- Mattress Firm Brownsburg: 7 brands to try, Brownsburg, 14.7 mi
- American Mattress North: 6 brands to try, North Indianapolis, 9.4 mi
Mattress stores in Carmel
We checked 22 stores within 8 miles of central Carmel. Of those, 19 are open on Sunday and 10 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Kittle's Indianapolis: 10 brands to try, Indianapolis, 5.3 mi
- American Mattress Indianapolis: 6 brands to try, Indianapolis, 5.3 mi
- Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East 86th Street): 5 brands to try, Indianapolis, 4.3 mi
Mattress stores in Fort Wayne
We checked 21 stores within 15 miles of central Fort Wayne. Of those, 10 are open on Sunday and 10 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- ABC Warehouse Ft. Wayne: 10 brands to try, Ft. Wayne, 2.1 mi
- Cloud Nine Mattress Company: 8 brands to try, Southwest Fort Wayne, 2.9 mi
- Mattress Firm North: 6 brands to try, North Fort Wayne, 6.2 mi
Mattress stores in Lawrence
We checked 20 stores within 8 miles of central Lawrence. Of those, 18 are open on Sunday and 8 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Kittle's Indianapolis: 10 brands to try, Indianapolis, 5.6 mi
- American Mattress Indianapolis: 8 brands to try, Indianapolis, 5.8 mi
- Mattress Firm Indianapolis (East Washington Street): 7 brands to try, Indianapolis, 6.3 mi
Mattress stores in Gary
We checked 17 stores within 10 miles of central Gary. Of those, 13 are open on Sunday and 11 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Ashley Merrillville: 7 brands to try, Merrillville, 8.7 mi
- Mattress Firm Highland: 6 brands to try, Highland, 7.8 mi
- JCPenney Merrillville: 5 brands to try, Merrillville, 8.8 mi
Mattress stores in Evansville
We checked 16 stores within 12 miles of central Evansville. Of those, 12 are open on Sunday and 3 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Evansville Overstock Warehouse: 8 brands to try, East Evansville, 2.4 mi
- Ashley East: 6 brands to try, East Evansville, 2.3 mi
- Big Sandy Superstore East: 6 brands to try, East Evansville, 2.8 mi
Mattress stores in Fishers
We checked 15 stores within 8 miles of central Fishers. Of those, 13 are open on Sunday and 5 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Kittle's Indianapolis: 10 brands to try, Indianapolis, 6.6 mi
- Mattress Firm Noblesville: 6 brands to try, Noblesville, 3.1 mi
- JCPenney Noblesville: 5 brands to try, Noblesville, 2.9 mi
Mattress stores in South Bend
We checked 14 stores within 12 miles of central South Bend. Of those, 9 are open on Sunday and 7 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Denver Mattress Mishawaka: 6 brands to try, Mishawaka, 4.4 mi
- ABC Warehouse Northeast: 6 brands to try, Northeast South Bend, 4.8 mi
- Mattress Firm Southeast: 6 brands to try, Southeast South Bend, 3.8 mi
Mattress stores in Greenwood
We checked 14 stores within 8 miles of central Greenwood. Of those, 13 are open on Sunday and 7 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Mattress Firm Outlet Central: 6 brands to try, Central Greenwood, 1.6 mi
- Furniture Fair Indianapolis: 5 brands to try, Indianapolis, 2.8 mi
- Ashley Northwest: 4 brands to try, Northwest Greenwood, 2.1 mi
Mattress stores in Mishawaka
We checked 13 stores within 10 miles of central Mishawaka. Of those, 8 are open on Sunday and 6 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Big Sandy Superstore Northwest: 7 brands to try, Northwest Mishawaka, 2.8 mi
- ABC Warehouse South Bend: 6 brands to try, South Bend, 2.6 mi
- Denver Mattress Central: 6 brands to try, Central Mishawaka, 1.8 mi
Mattress stores in Westfield
We checked 12 stores within 10 miles of central Westfield. Of those, 10 are open on Sunday and 5 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Mattress Firm Carmel: 7 brands to try, Carmel, 2.7 mi
- Village Mattress: 7 brands to try, Zionsville, 8.9 mi
- My Comfy Casa Mattress & Furniture: 3 brands to try, West Westfield, 3.4 mi
Mattress stores in Hammond
We checked 11 stores within 10 miles of central Hammond. Of those, 9 are open on Sunday and 5 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Ashley Highland: 6 brands to try, Highland, 6.5 mi
- Mattress Firm Homewood: 5 brands to try, Homewood, 8.2 mi
- BeX Furniture - Griffith: 4 brands to try, Griffith, 5.9 mi
Mattress stores in Lafayette
We checked 11 stores within 10 miles of central Lafayette. Of those, 7 are open on Sunday and 5 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Kittle's Central: 10 brands to try, Central Lafayette, 1.1 mi
- Mattress Superstore: 8 brands to try, Central Lafayette, 0.6 mi
- Denver Mattress Central: 6 brands to try, Central Lafayette, 0.4 mi
Mattress stores in Jeffersonville
We checked 11 stores within 10 miles of central Jeffersonville. Of those, 8 are open on Sunday and 4 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Sleep Outfitters West: 23 brands to try, West Jeffersonville, 2.7 mi
- Furniture Fair Clarksville: 14 brands to try, Clarksville, 3.9 mi
- Mattress Firm Clarksville: 4 brands to try, Clarksville, 4 mi
Mattress stores in Bloomington
We checked 10 stores within 10 miles of central Bloomington. Of those, 7 are open on Sunday and 5 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- American Rental Home Furnishings: 6 brands to try, West Bloomington, 3 mi
- Mattress Firm West: 4 brands to try, West Bloomington, 2.7 mi
- Ashley West: 4 brands to try, West Bloomington, 2.9 mi
Mattress stores in Terre Haute
We checked 10 stores within 10 miles of central Terre Haute. Of those, 6 are open on Sunday and 3 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Denver Mattress Southwest: 6 brands to try, Southwest Terre Haute, 3.8 mi
- Ashley Southwest: 5 brands to try, Southwest Terre Haute, 4.3 mi
- Furniture Row & Denver Mattress: 4 brands to try, Southwest Terre Haute, 3.8 mi
Mattress stores in Noblesville
We checked 8 stores within 8 miles of central Noblesville. Of those, 8 are open on Sunday and 3 post a policy that lets you return a bed. These three have the most brands to try in one trip:
- Mattress Firm Carmel: 7 brands to try, Carmel, 7 mi
- JCPenney Southeast: 5 brands to try, Southeast Noblesville, 4.9 mi
- Sleep Number Southeast: 1 brand to try, Southeast Noblesville, 4.7 mi
Rather shop from home?
Some people skip the showroom and buy online with a long home trial, since a month in your own bed tells you more than a few minutes in a store. Saatva is one example: you get 365 nights to try it at home and free setup in your room, and a return costs $99. Read our Saatva review, or compare it with other online brands.
How these lists are made
- Checked against each store's website. A store is listed only when its own page shows its street address and phone number, and the address sits inside the city's search area.
- Policies are quoted, not guessed. Delivery, old-bed removal and returns lines are exact quotes from the store's site. If we cannot find one, we say so.
- How we rank. We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, then by how many of their delivery, old-bed removal and return policies they post, counting one location per chain. Ties after that go to the closer store.
- No paid spots. Stores cannot pay to be listed or ranked. We do not test mattresses in a lab; we compare the facts stores publish.