The best mattress stores in and near Gary, Indiana

Updated October 18, 2026 · 17 stores, each checked against its own website

The best mattress stores in and near Gary are Ashley Merrillville, Mattress Firm Highland and JCPenney Merrillville. We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, then by how many of their delivery, old-bed removal and return policies they post, counting one location per chain. We checked 17 stores within 10 miles of central Gary, and no store pays to be listed.

  1. Ashley Merrillville: 7 brands to try, including Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster and Sealy. Merrillville, 8.7 mi, open Sunday; publishes a return policy.
  2. Mattress Firm Highland: 6 brands to try, including Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster and Purple. Highland, 7.8 mi, open Sunday; old-bed removal offered, publishes a return policy.
  3. JCPenney Merrillville: 5 brands to try, including Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster and Sealy. Merrillville, 8.8 mi, open Sunday; publishes a return policy.

A few minutes on a showroom bed will not tell you how it feels after a month at home. Pick a bed you trust from a store whose exchange and return policy you can live with: 11 of the 17 stores here post a policy that lets you return a bed, so read the fees and time limits before you buy.

See all 17 stores Find a brand
Stores checked
17
Brands listed
17
Open Sunday
13
Last checked
October 18
Gary City Hall and the Superior Courthouse on Broadway
Photo: Nyttend, Public domain
Top 3

Where to try the most beds in one trip

  1. First place Ashley Merrillville 7 brands to try Merrillville · 8.7 mi · Open Sunday Publishes 1 of 3 store policies
  2. Second place Mattress Firm Highland 6 brands to try Highland · 7.8 mi · Open Sunday Publishes 2 of 3 store policies
  3. Third place JCPenney Merrillville 5 brands to try Merrillville · 8.8 mi · Open Sunday Publishes 2 of 3 store policies

We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, then by how many of their delivery, old-bed removal and return policies they post, counting one location per chain. Ties after that go to the closer store, and stores cannot pay to be ranked.

Quick picks

Best Gary stores for what you need

Each pick comes from the facts below, not from payments. Tap one to jump to the store.

Closest to central Gary World Furniture 4.9 miles from central Gary at 1015 East Ridge Rd. Closest outlet Mattress, Furniture, and Appliance Store An outlet store 4.9 miles from central Gary, in Hobart. Open latest on weeknights Mattress Warehouse Highland Open until 8 pm on at least one weeknight, 8.1 miles out.
All stores

Every mattress store we checked in Gary

Sorted by distance from central Gary. Filter by what matters to you.

Show
Mattress type
Store type
Distance

Showing 17 of 17 stores

Furniture store · Griffith

World Furniture

4.9 mi from central Gary

(219) 513-90721015 East Ridge Rd, Griffith, IN 46319

  • Adjustable bases
Brands
  • Ashley Furniture Products
  • Beautyrest Simmons
Bed types
  • Memory foam
  • Hybrid
  • Innerspring
  • Adjustable base
Mon10 am-7 pm
Tue10 am-7 pm
Wed10 am-7 pm
Thu10 am-7 pm
Fri10 am-7 pm
Sat10 am-7 pm
SunClosed

Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress types and products, Ashley mattresses, Beautyrest mattresses. Report an error

Outlet · Hobart

Mattress, Furniture, and Appliance Store

4.9 mi from central Gary

(219) 508-67701055 W 37th Ave, Hobart, IN 46342

Bed types
  • Memory foam
  • Hybrid
  • Innerspring
Delivery
All Deliveries are done within a few days of purchase unless discussed and different arrangements are made.
Old bed
With that we do not in any circumstance take or haul away old mattresses.
Returns
All sales are final and there are NO returns.

Not listed by the store: brands, hours. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Official mattress page, Official terms and policies. Report an error

Outlet · Griffith

BeX Furniture - Griffith

5.3 mi from central Gary

(219) 212-2700120 W Ridge Rd, Griffith, IN 46319

  • Open Sunday
Brands
  • Sypedic
  • Belinda Celine
  • Harvest
  • Orthus
Delivery
We offer local delivery in Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin
Returns
Mattresses are not refundable.
Mon10 am-7 pm
Tue10 am-7 pm
Wed10 am-7 pm
Thu10 am-7 pm
Fri10 am-7 pm
Sat10 am-6 pm
Sun12 pm-5 pm

Not listed by the store: bed types, old-bed removal. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Our Brands, Delivery/Returns. Report an error

Outlet · Lake Station

NWI Appliance & Furniture Outlet

5.4 mi from central Gary

(219) 939-99803126 Central Ave, Lake Station, IN 46405

Delivery
Local delivery across Northwest Indiana, usually within the same week.
Mon9 am-6 pm
Tue9 am-6 pm
Wed9 am-6 pm
Thu9 am-6 pm
Fri9 am-5 pm
Sat9 am-4 pm
SunClosed

Not listed by the store: brands, bed types, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Contact and store hours, Delivery information. Report an error

Furniture store · Hammond

Signature Home Furniture

7 mi from central Gary

(219) 803-23597111 Indianapolis Blvd, Hammond, IN 46324

Returns
Stock merchandise orders may be canceled for a full refund up to 3 days before the scheduled delivery or pick-up date.
Mon10 am-7 pm
Tue10 am-7 pm
Wed10 am-7 pm
Thu10 am-7 pm
Fri10 am-7 pm
Sat10 am-7 pm
SunClosed

Not listed by the store: brands, bed types, delivery, old-bed removal. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattresses category, Return policy, Brands. Report an error

Chain store · Highland

Mattress Firm Highland

7.8 mi from central Gary

(219) 924-292210140 Indianapolis Boulevard Suite 100, Highland, IN 46322

  • Open Sunday
  • Adjustable bases
Brands
  • Sealy
  • Sleepy's
  • Stearns & Foster
  • Tempur-Pedic
  • Beautyrest
  • Purple
Bed types
  • Hybrid
  • Adjustable base
Old bed
Mattress Firm does offer haul off services on select items for an additional fee (excluding the State of California where haul off is included at no additional cost).
Returns
Our 120 Night Sleep Trial is valid for one exchange and/or one return per purchase. This must be done within 120 days of the delivery date of your originally purchased mattress.
Mon10 am-8 pm
Tue10 am-8 pm
Wed10 am-8 pm
Thu10 am-8 pm
Fri10 am-8 pm
Sat10 am-8 pm
Sun10 am-6 pm

Not listed by the store: delivery. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress Firm FAQ, Mattress Firm return policy. Report an error

Chain store · Highland

Ashley Highland

7.9 mi from central Gary

(219) 513-304010135 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland, IN 46322

  • Open Sunday
Brands
  • Tempur-Pedic
  • Simmons
  • Serta
  • Sealy
  • Stearns & Foster
  • Ashley Sleep
Bed types
  • Memory foam
  • Hybrid
Delivery
If you select White Glove Delivery, your items will be delivered, set in your room of choice and, if necessary, assembled.
Old bed
The delivery team will not move or take away existing furniture or furnishings.
Returns
In-store purchases, whether from independently owned and operated stores or from stores owned and operated by Ashley Global Retail, LLC or subsidiaries, set their own policies regarding returns and exchanges.
Mon10 am-9 pm
Tue10 am-9 pm
Wed10 am-9 pm
Thu10 am-9 pm
Fri10 am-9 pm
Sat10 am-9 pm
Sun12 pm-8 pm
Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Ashley delivery terms, Ashley returns policy. Report an error

Chain store · Highland

Mattress Warehouse Highland

8.1 mi from central Gary

(219) 224-331810412 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland, IN 46322

  • Open Sunday
Delivery
Available within the Mattress Warehouse delivery footprint, with next-day delivery available on eligible orders.
Old bed
Mattress Warehouse can remove and recycle your old mattress and/or box spring. There is a $29.99 charge for each item removed during delivery.
Returns
If you're not 100% satisfied after sleeping on your new mattress for at least 30 nights, you can exchange it. ... Please note that no refunds are provided.
Mon10 am-8 pm
Tue10 am-8 pm
Wed10 am-8 pm
Thu10 am-8 pm
Fri10 am-8 pm
Sat10 am-8 pm
Sun11 am-6 pm

Not listed by the store: brands, bed types. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Delivery and removal policy, Comfort guarantee policy. Report an error

Local store · Schererville

The Warehouse

8.5 mi from central Gary

(219) 515-22021042 US Hwy 41, Dock #6, Schererville, IN 46375

  • Open Sunday
Brands
  • GigaB2B
Bed types
  • Memory foam
Returns
Purchases made in person at The Warehouse are FINAL SALE.
Mon11 am-7 pm
Tue11 am-7 pm
Wed11 am-7 pm
Thu11 am-7 pm
Fri11 am-7 pm
Sat11 am-7 pm
Sun11 am-5 pm

Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Visit Us, walk-in location and hours, Mattress product listing, brand and type, Returns & Claims. Report an error

Chain store · Schererville

Mattress Firm Schererville

8.5 mi from central Gary

(219) 322-1079210 Indianapolis Boulevard Suite A, Schererville, IN 46375

  • Open Sunday
  • Adjustable bases
Brands
  • Sealy
  • Sleepy's
  • Stearns & Foster
  • Tempur-Pedic
  • Beautyrest Black
  • Purple
Bed types
  • Adjustable base
Mon10 am-8 pm
Tue10 am-8 pm
Wed10 am-8 pm
Thu10 am-8 pm
Fri10 am-8 pm
Sat10 am-8 pm
Sun10 am-6 pm

Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal, returns. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress Firm mattress removal article, Mattress Firm returns policy page. Report an error

Furniture store · Merrillville

Steinhafels Merrillville

8.5 mi from central Gary

(219) 233-51001600 E 80th Ave, Merrillville, IN 46410

  • Open Sunday
Delivery
Premier Delivery: Two delivery professionals will deliver, place items in your home, and assemble them (when applicable).
Old bed
For a small fee, we provide mattress removal, along with a protective bag for customers to cover the mattress before delivery to ensure safe handling.
Returns
You may return your mattress during your first 120 nights.
Mon10 am-8 pm
Tue10 am-8 pm
Wed10 am-8 pm
Thu10 am-8 pm
Fri10 am-8 pm
Sat10 am-7 pm
Sun11 am-6 pm

Not listed by the store: brands, bed types. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Steinhafels policies. Report an error

Chain store · Merrillville

Mattress Firm Merrillville

8.5 mi from central Gary

(219) 769-56431307 East 79th Avenue, Merrillville, IN 46410

  • Open Sunday
  • Adjustable bases
Brands
  • Sealy
  • Beautyrest
  • Tempur-Pedic
Bed types
  • Hybrid
  • Adjustable base
Old bed
Mattress Firm does offer haul off services on select items for an additional fee (excluding the State of California where haul off is included at no additional cost).
Returns
Our 120 Night Sleep Trial is valid for one exchange and/or one return per purchase.
Mon10 am-8 pm
Tue10 am-8 pm
Wed10 am-8 pm
Thu10 am-8 pm
Fri10 am-8 pm
Sat10 am-8 pm
Sun10 am-6 pm

Not listed by the store: delivery. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, FAQ, Returns policy. Report an error

Furniture store · Merrillville

Ashley Merrillville

8.7 mi from central Gary

(219) 576-74231550 E Lincoln Highway, Merrillville, IN 46410

  • Open Sunday
  • Adjustable bases
Brands
  • Tempur-Pedic
  • Simmons
  • Serta
  • Sealy
  • Stearns & Foster
  • Ashley Sleep
  • Beautyrest
Bed types
  • Memory foam
  • Hybrid
  • Adjustable base
Returns
Returns on mattresses or foundations are controlled by the manufacturer's warranty, if any.
Mon10 am-9 pm
Tue10 am-9 pm
Wed10 am-9 pm
Thu10 am-9 pm
Fri10 am-9 pm
Sat10 am-9 pm
Sun12 pm-8 pm

Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Ashley Returns Policy, Ashley Delivery Methods. Report an error

Outlet · Munster

Mattress Firm Outlet Munster

8.7 mi from central Gary

(219) 836-58728219 Calumet Avenue, Munster, IN 46321

  • Open Sunday
  • Adjustable bases
Brands
  • Sealy
  • Stearns & Foster
  • Tempur-Pedic
  • Beautyrest
Bed types
  • Hybrid
  • Adjustable base
Delivery
Mattress Firm does offer setup services on select items for an additional fee.
Old bed
Mattress Firm does offer haul off services on select items for an additional fee.
Returns
Our 120 Night Sleep Trial is not valid on clearance, outlet, or preowned merchandise, floor and display models, pillows, mattress protectors, adjustable bases other than TEMPUR-ActiveBreeze Smart Bed adjustable bases, furniture or other accessories.
Mon10 am-8 pm
Tue10 am-8 pm
Wed10 am-8 pm
Thu10 am-8 pm
Fri10 am-8 pm
Sat10 am-8 pm
Sun10 am-6 pm
Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress Firm FAQ, Mattress Firm returns policy. Report an error

Chain store · Merrillville

JCPenney Merrillville

8.8 mi from central Gary

(219) 738-21551890 Southlake Mall, Merrillville, IN 46410

  • Open Sunday
Brands
  • Sealy
  • Serta
  • Tempur-pedic
  • Stearns & Foster
  • Beautyrest
Bed types
  • Memory foam
  • Hybrid
  • Innerspring
  • Airbed
Delivery
Get our White Glove Delivery service with any mattress purchase (for free on mattress purchases $699 & up) within the 48 contiguous United States.
Returns
Mattresses must be returned within 120 days of delivery.
Mon11 am-8 pm
Tue11 am-8 pm
Wed11 am-8 pm
Thu11 am-8 pm
Fri10 am-9 pm
Sat10 am-9 pm
Sun11 am-7 pm

Not listed by the store: old-bed removal. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page. Report an error

Chain store · Portage

Mattress Firm Portage

8.9 mi from central Gary

(219) 762-64906046 US Highway 6, Portage, IN 46368

  • Open Sunday
  • Adjustable bases
Brands
  • Sealy
  • Sleepy's
  • Tempur-Pedic
  • Beautyrest
Bed types
  • Adjustable base
MonNot listed
Tue10 am-8 pm
Wed10 am-8 pm
Thu10 am-8 pm
Fri10 am-8 pm
Sat10 am-8 pm
Sun10 am-6 pm

Not listed by the store: delivery, old-bed removal, returns, Monday hours. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Mattress Firm delivery options, Mattress Firm return policy. Report an error

Furniture store · Schererville

Furniture Depot

9.6 mi from central Gary

(219) 440-75571644 US Highway 41, Schererville, IN 46375

  • Open Sunday
Bed types
  • Memory foam
  • Hybrid
  • Innerspring
Returns
If you are unsatisfied for any reason with your purchase, you can return or exchange it within 30 days of delivery.
Mon10 am-7 pm
Tue10 am-7 pm
Wed10 am-7 pm
Thu10 am-7 pm
Fri10 am-7 pm
Sat10 am-6 pm
Sun11 am-5 pm

Not listed by the store: brands, delivery, old-bed removal. Call to ask.

Call Directions Website

Checked against the store's website on October 18, 2026. Policy lines are quoted from its pages: Official store page, Furniture Depot home page and mattress categories, Return Policy. Report an error

Side by side

Compare prices, delivery and returns

The fine print is where stores differ most: delivery, old-bed removal and return fees.

Swipe sideways to see every column.

StoreDistanceDeliveryOld bedReturnsSunday
World Furniture 4.9 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. Closed
Mattress, Furniture, and Appliance Store 4.9 mi All Deliveries are done within a few days of purchase unless discussed and different... Full text With that we do not in any circumstance take or haul away old mattresses. All sales are final and there are NO returns. Not listed
BeX Furniture - Griffith 5.3 mi We offer local delivery in Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin Not listed. Call to ask. Mattresses are not refundable. 12 pm-5 pm
NWI Appliance & Furniture Outlet 5.4 mi Local delivery across Northwest Indiana, usually within the same week. Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. Closed
Signature Home Furniture 7 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. Stock merchandise orders may be canceled for a full refund up to 3 days before the... Full text Closed
Mattress Firm Highland 7.8 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Mattress Firm does offer haul off services on select items for an additional fee... Full text Our 120 Night Sleep Trial is valid for one exchange and/or one return per purchase.... Full text 10 am-6 pm
Ashley Highland 7.9 mi If you select White Glove Delivery, your items will be delivered, set in your room of... Full text The delivery team will not move or take away existing furniture or furnishings. In-store purchases, whether from independently owned and operated stores or from stores... Full text 12 pm-8 pm
Mattress Warehouse Highland 8.1 mi Available within the Mattress Warehouse delivery footprint, with next-day delivery... Full text Mattress Warehouse can remove and recycle your old mattress and/or box spring. There is... Full text If you're not 100% satisfied after sleeping on your new mattress for at least 30... Full text 11 am-6 pm
The Warehouse 8.5 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. Purchases made in person at The Warehouse are FINAL SALE. 11 am-5 pm
Mattress Firm Schererville 8.5 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. 10 am-6 pm
Steinhafels Merrillville 8.5 mi Premier Delivery: Two delivery professionals will deliver, place items in your home,... Full text For a small fee, we provide mattress removal, along with a protective bag for customers... Full text You may return your mattress during your first 120 nights. 11 am-6 pm
Mattress Firm Merrillville 8.5 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Mattress Firm does offer haul off services on select items for an additional fee... Full text Our 120 Night Sleep Trial is valid for one exchange and/or one return per purchase. 10 am-6 pm
Ashley Merrillville 8.7 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. Returns on mattresses or foundations are controlled by the manufacturer's warranty, if... Full text 12 pm-8 pm
Mattress Firm Outlet Munster 8.7 mi Mattress Firm does offer setup services on select items for an additional fee. Mattress Firm does offer haul off services on select items for an additional fee. Our 120 Night Sleep Trial is not valid on clearance, outlet, or preowned merchandise,... Full text 10 am-6 pm
JCPenney Merrillville 8.8 mi Get our White Glove Delivery service with any mattress purchase (for free on mattress... Full text Not listed. Call to ask. Mattresses must be returned within 120 days of delivery. 11 am-7 pm
Mattress Firm Portage 8.9 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. 10 am-6 pm
Furniture Depot 9.6 mi Not listed. Call to ask. Not listed. Call to ask. If you are unsatisfied for any reason with your purchase, you can return or exchange it... Full text 11 am-5 pm
By brand

Where to find each brand in Gary

Want to lie on a certain bed before you buy it? Find every checked store that lists it, then call ahead to make sure it is on the floor.

BrandStoresWhere to try it
Sealy 8 Mattress Firm Highland, Ashley Highland, Mattress Firm Schererville, Mattress Firm Merrillville, Ashley Merrillville, Mattress Firm Outlet Munster, JCPenney Merrillville, Mattress Firm Portage
Tempur-Pedic 8 Mattress Firm Highland, Ashley Highland, Mattress Firm Schererville, Mattress Firm Merrillville, Ashley Merrillville, Mattress Firm Outlet Munster, JCPenney Merrillville, Mattress Firm Portage
Beautyrest 6 Mattress Firm Highland, Mattress Firm Merrillville, Ashley Merrillville, Mattress Firm Outlet Munster, JCPenney Merrillville, Mattress Firm Portage
Stearns & Foster 6 Mattress Firm Highland, Ashley Highland, Mattress Firm Schererville, Ashley Merrillville, Mattress Firm Outlet Munster, JCPenney Merrillville
Serta 3 Ashley Highland, Ashley Merrillville, JCPenney Merrillville
Sleepy's 3 Mattress Firm Highland, Mattress Firm Schererville, Mattress Firm Portage
Ashley Sleep 2 Ashley Highland, Ashley Merrillville
Purple 2 Mattress Firm Highland, Mattress Firm Schererville
Simmons 2 Ashley Highland, Ashley Merrillville
Ashley Furniture Products 1 World Furniture
Beautyrest Black 1 Mattress Firm Schererville
Beautyrest Simmons 1 World Furniture
Belinda Celine 1 BeX Furniture - Griffith
GigaB2B 1 The Warehouse
Harvest 1 BeX Furniture - Griffith
Orthus 1 BeX Furniture - Griffith
Sypedic 1 BeX Furniture - Griffith
By ZIP code

Mattress stores by Gary ZIP code

We searched every ZIP code within 10 miles of central Gary for stores. Distances are straight-line miles from the middle of each ZIP code.

ZIPStores within 5 miNearest storeWhat is close by
46312 1 Signature Home Furniture, 4.5 mi 1 store is within 5 miles.
46319 8 World Furniture, 1.7 mi 8 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Sealy, Stearns & Foster, Tempur-Pedic.
46321 10 Mattress Firm Outlet Munster, 1.1 mi 10 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Sealy, Stearns & Foster, Tempur-Pedic.
46322 10 Mattress Firm Highland, 1.1 mi 10 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Sealy, Stearns & Foster, Tempur-Pedic.
46323 7 Signature Home Furniture, 1.4 mi 7 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Sealy, Stearns & Foster, Tempur-Pedic.
46324 9 Signature Home Furniture, 1.1 mi 9 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Sealy, Stearns & Foster, Tempur-Pedic.
46327 2 Signature Home Furniture, 3.1 mi 2 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Sealy, Stearns & Foster.
46342 6 Mattress, Furniture, and Appliance Store, 2.7 mi 6 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Sealy, Serta.
46368 2 Mattress Firm Portage, 2.8 mi 2 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Sealy, Sleepy's.
46375 8 Furniture Depot, 1.2 mi 8 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Sealy, Stearns & Foster, Tempur-Pedic.
46394 0 Signature Home Furniture, 6.5 mi No store we checked is within 5 miles. The closest is 6.5 miles away.
46402 2 Mattress, Furniture, and Appliance Store, 4.5 mi 2 stores are within 5 miles.
46403 2 NWI Appliance & Furniture Outlet, 2.5 mi 2 stores are within 5 miles.
46404 2 World Furniture, 3.2 mi 2 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Ashley Furniture Products, Beautyrest Simmons, Belinda Celine.
46405 3 NWI Appliance & Furniture Outlet, 0.8 mi 3 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Sealy, Sleepy's.
46406 3 World Furniture, 3.7 mi 3 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Ashley Furniture Products, Beautyrest Simmons, Belinda Celine.
46407 3 Mattress, Furniture, and Appliance Store, 3.5 mi 3 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Ashley Furniture Products, Beautyrest Simmons.
46408 3 World Furniture, 2.5 mi 3 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Ashley Furniture Products, Beautyrest Simmons, Belinda Celine.
46409 3 Mattress, Furniture, and Appliance Store, 2.7 mi 3 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Ashley Furniture Products, Beautyrest Simmons.
46410 4 Mattress Firm Merrillville, 0.7 mi 4 stores are within 5 miles. Brands listed nearby: Beautyrest, Sealy, Serta.
Know before you go

Buying a mattress in Gary: local rules and tips

Sales tax on a mattress

Lake County sales tax is 7.00% (Indiana's state rate), so a $1,000 mattress costs $70 in tax.

Source: Indiana Department of Revenue, sales tax, checked October 18, 2026.

How to test a bed in the store

Lie down in the position you sleep in. Bring your own pillow. Ask for the exact model name on paper so you can compare it with other stores.

Questions

Questions about mattress stores in Gary

Which mattress stores in Gary are open on Sunday?

13 of the 17 stores we checked open on Sunday: BeX Furniture - Griffith (12 pm to 5 pm), Mattress Firm Highland (10 am to 6 pm), Ashley Highland (12 pm to 8 pm), Mattress Warehouse Highland (11 am to 6 pm), The Warehouse (11 am to 5 pm), Mattress Firm Schererville (10 am to 6 pm), Steinhafels Merrillville (11 am to 6 pm), Mattress Firm Merrillville (10 am to 6 pm), Ashley Merrillville (12 pm to 8 pm), Mattress Firm Outlet Munster (10 am to 6 pm), JCPenney Merrillville (11 am to 7 pm), Mattress Firm Portage (10 am to 6 pm), Furniture Depot (11 am to 5 pm). Hours were checked on the dates shown on each store.

Where can I try Sealy in Gary?

8 checked stores list Sealy on their own sites: Mattress Firm Highland in Highland, Ashley Highland in Highland, Mattress Firm Schererville in Schererville, Mattress Firm Merrillville in Merrillville, Ashley Merrillville in Merrillville, Mattress Firm Outlet Munster in Munster, JCPenney Merrillville in Merrillville, Mattress Firm Portage in Portage. Call ahead to make sure it is on the showroom floor.

Where can I try Tempur-Pedic in Gary?

8 checked stores list Tempur-Pedic on their own sites: Mattress Firm Highland in Highland, Ashley Highland in Highland, Mattress Firm Schererville in Schererville, Mattress Firm Merrillville in Merrillville, Ashley Merrillville in Merrillville, Mattress Firm Outlet Munster in Munster, JCPenney Merrillville in Merrillville, Mattress Firm Portage in Portage. Call ahead to make sure it is on the showroom floor.

Do stores pay to be on this page?

No. We list every store that passes our checks, sorted by distance. Picks are based on the facts shown, such as hours, brands and published policies.

How we check

How we built this list

Nearby

Mattress stores near Gary

All Indiana cities

Find Your Evidence-Backed Match

Need a personalized mattress recommendation?

Answer 6 quick questions about how you sleep, your preferences, and your bed base to compare mattress matches.

Take the Sleep Quiz → Compare Mattresses Side-by-Side
Non-toxic fire barriers Under 60 seconds No email required