Updated October 15, 2026 · 9 stores, each checked against its own website
The best mattress stores in and near Elyria are Sleep Outfitters Southeast, Mattress Firm Southeast and American Freight Central. We rank stores by how many mattress brands you can try in person, and these three list the most: 23, 6 and 3 brands. We checked 9 stores within 8 miles of central Elyria, and no store pays to be listed.
Sleep Outfitters Southeast: 23 brands to try, including Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster and Purple. Southeast Elyria, 2.9 mi, open Sunday; $29.99 per item old-bed removal, no returns.
Mattress Firm Southeast: 6 brands to try, including Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster and Sealy. Southeast Elyria, 2.9 mi, open Sunday; old-bed removal offered, publishes a return policy.
American Freight Central: 3 brands to try: Serta, Whitmore and Tranquility. Central Elyria, 1.9 mi, open Sunday; publishes a return policy.
How we rank: the most mattress brands listed for in-store shopping, one location per business. Ties go to the store that publishes more of its delivery, removal and returns policies, then to the closer one. Stores cannot pay to be ranked.
Quick picks
Best Elyria stores for what you need
Each pick comes from the facts below, not from payments. Tap one to jump to the store.
Yes. American Freight offers local furniture and mattress delivery for many purchases. Delivery availability, pricing, and scheduling depend on your location, the items ordered, and inventory availability.
Returns
Items purchased at American Freight ‐ Furniture, Mattress, Appliance Stores are not eligible for return, refund, or exchange after pick-up or delivery has been completed.
Mon
10 am-7 pm
Tue
10 am-7 pm
Wed
10 am-7 pm
Thu
10 am-7 pm
Fri
10 am-7 pm
Sat
10 am-7 pm
Sun
11 am-6 pm
Not listed by the store: old-bed removal. Call to ask.
At Mattress Firm, delivering your new bed to your doorstep is always free, regardless of if you bought the mattress online or in-store.
Old bed
With this delivery option, the Mattress Firm delivery team will remove your old bed and box spring.
Returns
Our 120 Night Sleep Trial is valid for one exchange and/or one return per purchase. This must be done within 120 days of the delivery date of your originally purchased mattress.
Yes, we are able to deliver to anywhere in the continental United States. We offer a number of options depending on your location.
Old bed
We can remove your old bedding for an additional charge. We will, however, refuse to remove any bedding that is in an unsanitary condition or has protruding wires or broken wood.
Returns
We do not accept returns or exchanges due to the fact that we only sell brand new products.
Mon
10 am-8 pm
Tue
10 am-8 pm
Wed
10 am-8 pm
Thu
10 am-8 pm
Fri
10 am-8 pm
Sat
10 am-5 pm
Sun
12 pm-5 pm
Not listed by the store: brands, bed types. Call to ask.
Lorain County sales tax is 6.50% (5.75% state plus local), so a $1,000 mattress costs $65 in tax. Stores in nearby counties may charge a different rate.
Lie down in the position you sleep in. Bring your own pillow. Ask for the exact model name on paper so you can compare it with other stores.
Questions
Questions about mattress stores in Elyria
Which mattress stores in Elyria are open on Sunday?
8 of the 9 stores we checked open on Sunday: Sandy's Value Furniture and decor (12 pm to 5 pm), American Freight Central (11 am to 6 pm), Mattress Firm Southeast (10 am to 6 pm), Sleep Outfitters Southeast (12 pm to 6 pm), At Home Northeast (9 am to 9 pm), Mattress Firm Lorain (10 am to 6 pm), Mattress Firm Avon (10 am to 6 pm), Original Mattress Factory Avon (12 pm to 5 pm). Hours were checked on the dates shown on each store.
Where can I try Sealy in Elyria?
4 checked stores list Sealy on their own sites: Mattress Firm Southeast in Southeast Elyria, Sleep Outfitters Southeast in Southeast Elyria, Mattress Firm Lorain in Lorain, Mattress Firm Avon in Avon. Call ahead to make sure it is on the showroom floor.
Where can I try Tempur-Pedic in Elyria?
4 checked stores list Tempur-Pedic on their own sites: Mattress Firm Southeast in Southeast Elyria, Sleep Outfitters Southeast in Southeast Elyria, Mattress Firm Lorain in Lorain, Mattress Firm Avon in Avon. Call ahead to make sure it is on the showroom floor.
Do stores pay to be on this page?
No. We list every store that passes our checks, sorted by distance. Picks are based on the facts shown, such as hours, brands and published policies.
How we check
How we built this list
Every fact has a source. Hours, brands and policies come from the store's own website. Each store links its sources. We do not print prices, because they change too often to keep right.
Two checks per store. A search finds the store. Then a script opens the store's own page and confirms the street address and phone number are on it, and that every policy line we quote is still there word for word. A store that fails is left off. Checks used for this page: Script check against the store's website; Store search (AI). The date on each store is the latest check.
Open stores only. We confirm each store is open within 90 days of the update date. Closed stores come off the page.
Within 8 miles. We only list stores within 8 miles of central Elyria.
No paid spots. Stores cannot pay to be listed or ranked. We do not test mattresses in a lab; we compare the facts stores publish.
